 |  |
Central PA Smurf Bowl
*Mobile users scroll for entire table*
| Year | Format | League/Conf | Champion | Runner Up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | All CFA | CFA | Susquehanna Tribe | Steelton Raiders |
| 2024 | By Conf. | National CFA | Susquehanna Tribe | |
| 2024 | By Conf. | Federal East CFA | Steelton Raiders | |
| 2024 | By Conf. | Federal West CFA | Red Land Patriots | New Cumberland Colts |
| 2024 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Shamrocks | Big Spring Bulldogs |
| 2023 | By Conf. | National CFA | Susquehanna Tribe | New Cumberland Colts |
| 2023 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | Steelton Rollers | Carlisle Herd |
| 2023 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Tri-Community Panthers | Hershey Trojans |
| 2022 | By Conf. | National CFA | Susquehanna Tribe | Cumberland Valley Eagles |
| 2022 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | Chambersburg Trojans | Red Land Patriots |
| 2022 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Tri-Community Panthers | |
| 2021 | By Conf. | National CFA | Harrisburg Cougars | Red Land Patriots |
| 2021 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | West Perry Mustangs | Mechanicsburg Wildcats |
| 2021 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Northern Lebanon Vikings | Palmyra Cougars |
| 2020 | Independent | Indepenent Conference | New Cumberland Colts | Central Dauphin Rams |
| 2019 | By Conf. | National CFA | Harrisburg Cougars | Central Penn Crusaders |
| 2019 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | ||
| 2019 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Northern Lebanon Vikings | Big Spring Bulldogs |
| 2019 | MPE | MPE | York Bears | Steelton Rollers |
| 2018 | By Conf. | National CFA | Susquehanna Indians | New Cumberland Saints |
| 2018 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | Good Shepherd Rams | |
| 2018 | By Conf. | Liberty CFA | Big Spring Bulldogs | |
| 2017 | By Conf. | National CFA | New Cumberland Saints | Carlisle Herd |
| 2017 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | West Perry Mustangs | Seven Sorrows Eagles |
| 2016 | By Conf. | American CFA | Harrisburg Broncos | |
| 2016 | By Conf. | National CFA | New Cumberland Saints | Susquehanna Indians |
| 2016 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | Hershey Trojans | |
| 2015 | By Conf. | American CFA | Holy Name Jets | Harrisburg Broncos |
| 2015 | By Conf. | National CFA | Cedar Cliff Colts | |
| 2015 | By Conf. | Federal CFA | Gettysburg Warriors | |
| 2014 | By Conf. | |||
| 2013 | All CFA | CFA | York Bears | |
| 2012 | All CFA | CFA | York Bears | |
| 2011 | KMFC | |||
| 2011 | All CFA | American CFA | Swatara Tigers | New Cumberland Saints |
| 2010 | KMFC | |||
| 2009 | Smurfbowl | KMFC/CFA | Harrisburg Packers | Swatara Tigers |
| 2008 | KMFC | KMFC | Harrisburg Packers | |
| 2007 | KMFC | |||
| 2006 | KMFC | |||
| 2005 | KMFC | |||
| 2004 | KMFC | KMFC | Linglestown Colts | Middletown Blue Raiders |
| 2003 | KMFC | |||
| 2002 | KMFC |