 |  |
CFA Pony Superbowls
*Mobile users scroll for entire table*
| Super Bowl | Conf. | Year | CFA Pony Champs | W | L | CFA Pony Runner Up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| L | National | 2022 | State College Lions | 19 | 6 | Central Penn Crusaders |
| L | Federal | 2022 | Northern Polar Bears | 16 | West Perry Mustangs | |
| L | Liberty | 2022 | Tri-Community Panthers | 21 | 14 | Big Spring Bulldogs |
| XLIX | National | 2021 | Central Penn Crusaders | 53 | 19 | Susquehanna Indians |
| XLIX | Federal | 2021 | Northern Polar Bears | 16 | 6 | West Perry Mustangs |
| XLIX | Liberty | 2021 | Northern Lebanon Vikings | 33 | 13 | Greenwood Buffaloes |
| XLVIII | Independent | 2020 | New Cumberland Colts | 40 | Waynesboro Stallions | |
| XLVII | National | 2019 | Central Penn Crusaders | 24 | Cumberland Valley Eagles | |
| XLVII | Federal | 2019 | Cedar Cliff Colts | 16 | 13 | East Pennsboro Panthers |
| XLVII | Liberty | 2019 | Gettysburg Warriors | 38 | Good Shepherd Rams | |
| XLVI | National | 2018 | Susquehanna Indians | 20 | 14 | Harrisburg Cougars |
| XLVI | Federal | 2018 | East Pennsboro Panthers | 26 | 13 | Cedar Cliff Colts |
| XLVI | Liberty | 2018 | Seven Sorrows Eagles | 12 | 7 | Gettysburg Warriors |
| XLV | National | 2017 | Mechanicsburg Wildcats | 20 | Susquehanna Indians | |
| XLV | Federal | 2017 | Good Shepherd | 26 | 19 | West Perry Mustangs |
| XLIV | American | 2016 | York Bears | 26 | 6 | Harrisburg Broncos |
| XLIV | National | 2016 | Red Land Patriots | 12 | 8 | West Perry Mustangs |
| XLIV | Federal | 2016 | Seven Sorrows Eagles | 28 | 12 | Boiling Springs Bengals |
| XLIII | American | 2015 | York Bears | 15 | 6 | Harrisburg Packers |
| XLIII | National | 2015 | Middletown Blue Raiders | 31 | 6 | New Cumberland Saints |
| XLIII | Federal | 2015 | West Perry Mustangs | 12 | 2 | Shippensburg Greyhounds |
| XLII | American | 2014 | Harrisburg Broncos | 20 | 7 | York Bears |
| XLII | National | 2014 | Mechanicsburg Wildcats | 8 | 6 | Steelton Raiders |
| XLII | Federal | 2014 | West Perry Mustangs | 30 | 14 | Good Shepherd Rams |
| XLI | American | 2013 | Holy Name Jets | 12 | Red Land Patriots | |
| XLI | National | 2013 | Steelton Raiders | 19 | 8 | Mechanicsburg WIldcats |
| XLI | Federal | 2013 | West Perry Mustangs | 12 | Northern Polar Bears | |
| XL | American | 2012 | Holy Name Jets | 38 | 18 | York Bears |
| XL | National | 2012 | Cedar Cliff Colts | 13 | Mechanicsburg Wildcats | |
| XL | Federal | 2012 | Boiling Springs Bengals | 18 | Halifax Bobcats | |
| XXXIX | American | 2011 | Good Shepherd Rams | 13 | 6 | York Bears |
| XXXIX | National | 2011 | Swatara Tigers | 28 | 6 | New Cumberland Saints |
| XXXVIII | American | 2010 | Holy Name Jets | 20 | 6 | Northern Polar Bears |
| XXXVIII | National | 2010 | Boiling Springs Bengals | 24 | St. Joseph Chargers | |
| XXXVII | American | 2009 | Good Shepherd Rams | 28 | 19 | Harrisburg Broncos |
| XXXVII | National | 2009 | St. Joseph Chargers | 25 | 13 | Northern Polar Bears |
| XXXVI | American | 2008 | Good Shepherd Rams | 33 | 30 | Holy Name Jets |
| XXXVI | National | 2008 | Boiling Springs Bengals | 14 | 6 | Susquenita Blackhawks |
| XXXV | American | 2007 | Swatara Tigers | 25 | 6 | Cedar Cliff Cowboys |
| XXXV | National | 2007 | New Cumberland Saints | 24 | South Hanover Knights | |
| XXXIV | CFA | 2006 | Harrisburg Broncos | 20 | Northern Polar Bears | |
| XXXIII | CFA | 2005 | Harrisburg Broncos | 19 | Juniata Little Indians | |
| XXXII | CFA | 2004 | Swatara Tigers | 19 | Lower Allen Cowboys | |
| XXXI | CFA | 2003 | Holy Name Jets | 19 | 18 | Harrisburg Broncos |
| XXX | CFA | 2002 | East Shore Royals | 14 | 6 | Good Shepherd Rams |
| XXIX | CFA | 2001 | Swatara Tigers | 19 | Halifax Bobcats | |
| XXVIII | CFA | 2000 | East Shore Royals | 31 | 6 | Dauphin Jaguars |
| XXVII | CFA | 1999 | West Perry Mustangs | 30 | 14 | St. Joseph Chargers |
| XXVI | CFA | 1998 | Halifax Bobcats | 14 | 7 | Good Shepherd Rams |
| XXV | CFA | 1997 | St. Joseph Chargers | 6 | East Shore Royals | |
| XXIV | CFA | 1996 | Capital City Spartans | 6 | Boiling Springs Bengals | |
| XXIII | CFA | 1995 | Capital City Spartans | 14 | 6 | East Shore Royals |
| XXII | CFA | 1994 | West Perry Mustangs | 6 | East Shore Royals | |
| XXI | CFA | 1993 | East Shore Royals | 12 | 6 | West Perry Mustangs |
| XX | CFA | 1992 | East Shore Royals | 19 | 6 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans |
| XIX | CFA | 1991 | Holy Name Jets | 13 | 6 | West Perry Mustangs |
| XVIII | CFA | 1990 | East Shore Royals | Holy Name Jets | ||
| XVII | CFA | 1989 | West Perry Mustangs | 13 | 6 | Holy Name Jets |
| XVI | CFA | 1988 | St. Joseph Chargers | 6 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | |
| XV | CFA | 1987 | Holy Name Jets | 18 | 6 | East Shore Royals |
| XIV | CFA | 1986 | Holy Name Jets | 33 | 6 | St. Theresa Saints |
| XIII | CFA | 1985 | East Shore Royals | 18 | Holy Name Jets | |
| XII | CFA | 1984 | St. Theresa Saints | 24 | East Shore Royals | |
| XI | CFA | 1983 | St. Theresa Saints | 7 | 6 | St. Joseph Chargers |
| X | CFA | 1982 | No Information | No Information | ||
| IX | CFA | 1981 | St. Joseph Chargers | 14 | 8 | Seven Sorrows Eagles |
| VIII | CFA | 1980 | St. Joseph Chargers | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | ||
| VII | CFA | 1979 | Holy Name Jets | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | ||
| VI | CFA | 1978 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | Holy Name Jets | ||
| V | CFA | 1977 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | St. Theresa Saints | ||
| IV | CFA | 1976 | St. Catherine Laboure Royals | 14 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | |
| III | CFA | 1975 | Susquehanna Indians | 6 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | |
| II | CFA | 1974 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | St. Catherine Laboure Royals | ||
| I | CFA | 1973 | St. Margaret Mary Spartans | 24 | 8 | St. Theresa Saints |